Cake Menu


Traditional Flavors

All prices include delivery but do not reflect a 9% sales tax. Unfortunately at this time we do not deliver more than 20 miles outside of downtown Indianapolis. Please note that prices listed below may be more based on additional requested details, frosting design, fondant, etc.

White Wedding Vanilla
Our top seller! A thick, white cake with a fluffy vanilla buttercream frosting between three layers

Triple Chocolate
A thick chocolate cake with a creamy chocolate buttercream frosting between three layers

Fresh Strawberry
A thick strawberry cake made with fresh strawberries with a fluffy vanilla buttercream frosting between three layers

Classic Yellow
Traditional, delicious yellow cake with vanilla or chocolate buttercream frosting between three layers

Marble
A thick half chocolate and half vanilla cake with a fluffy vanilla buttercream frosting between three layers

Sprinkles
Our white wedding vanilla cake with an unreal amount of sprinkles folded in with a fluffy vanilla buttercream & garnished with more sprinkles

Dark Chocolate
A dark chocolate cake with a fluffy dark chocolate buttercream frosting

Traditional Cake Flavor Pricing
6″ (feeds 5-7) : $50
8″ (feeds 10-15) : $70
10″ (feeds 18-25) : $103
12″ (feeds 25-35) : $136
*Includes delivery within 25 miles of downtown Indianapolis but does not include 9% tax

Premium Flavors:

All prices include delivery but do not reflect a 9% sales tax. Unfortunately at this time we do not deliver more than 20 miles outside of downtown Indianapolis. Please note that prices listed below may be more based on additional requested details, frosting design, fondant, etc.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
A delicious, thick white cake with chunks of chocolate chip between each layer of cake with a chocolate chip cookie dough frosting garnished with chocolate chips

Mint Chocolate Chip
A chocolate cake with chocolate chips baked in with a light green, mint frosting. The entire cake is then covered in chocolate ganache

Cookies & Cream
Layers of chocolate cake Cookies & Cream frosting and chopped Oreos between each layer

Banana Pudding
A banana flavored cake with a banana pudding filling between each layer with a fluffy vanilla buttercream frosting. The whole cake is then frosted and garnished with vanilla wafers

Snickerdoodle
A savory vanilla, cinnamon cake with a fluffy vanilla, cinnamon frosting between each layer with snickerdoodle cookie crumbles garnished on top of the cake

Strawberry Champagne
A thick, fresh strawberry cake with a fluffy vanilla buttercream infused with a delicious champagne flavor topped with fresh strawberries

Strawberry Cheesecake
A thick, vanilla cake with a fresh, strawberry filling between three layers with a whipped cream cheese frosting & graham cracker dust

Brownie Batter
A chocolate, brownie cake with a creamy vanilla buttercream between three layers garnished with brownie bits & a chocolate drizzle

French Toast
A cinnamon cake with a fluffy cinnamon, vanilla frosting garnished with candied bacon & maple syrup. Have cake for breakfast!

Carrot Cake
A thick, delicious carrot cake with fresh carrots, raisins & pecans. This frosting is a fluffy cream cheese frosting with candied pecans

Frosted Animal Cracker
A thick, white vanilla cake with chopped frosted animal cracker bits baked in. The frosting is a pink or white vanilla buttercream with more chopped bits & sprinkles

Peanut Butter Chocolate
Three layers of a thick chocolate cake with a whipped peanut butter frosting between each layer. The entire cake is then coated in chocolate ganache and more peanut butter frosting

Oatmeal Creme Pie
A cinnamon, vanilla cake with Oatmeal Creme Pie chunks, a marshmallow frosting with more Oatmeal Creme Pie cookie chunks between each layer & garnished on top

Caramel Pumpkin Spice Donut Cake
Three layers of a delicious, thick pumpkin cake, a fluffy cinnamon buttercream, homemade buttery caramel & pumpkin spice donut bits between each layer. The whole cake is covered in cinnamon buttercream and garnished with more caramel and of course donuts *Seasonal: available until 10/30

Butterfinger
A peanut butter cupcake with Butterfinger bits baked into the cake. This cake has a peanut butter frosting and is garnished with more Butterfinger bits

Caramel Apple
A cinnamon, vanilla cake with layers of a fresh apple filling with a cinnamon frosting drizzled with a homemade caramel and chopped peanuts

Almond Joy
A chocolate cake with a fluffy, fresh coconut frosting with a chocolate ganache garnished with fresh coconut

S’mores
A chocolate cake with a delicious marshmallow, vanilla buttercream frosting with roasted marshmallows and graham cracker crust garnished on top

Lemon Raspberry
A thick, lemon cake with a fresh, sweet raspberry filling between each layer. The whole cake is garnished with a fluffy vanilla buttercream and fresh raspberries

Key Lime
A fresh key lime cake with a creamy vanilla buttercream between three layers garnished with a fresh lime & graham cracker dust

Pumpkin Cinnamon Roll
A thick, pumpkin cake with cinnamon rolls baked into each cake layer. This cake has a light cinnamon cream cheese frosting and is garnished with small cinnamon rolls

Chocolate Coffee Toffee
A thick, chocolate coffee cake with bits of toffee baked in. The cake has a light coffee buttercream frosting & is a garnished with more toffee bits between each layer & on top

Caramel Apple Cake Three layers of a cinnamon apple cake, layers of a fluffy cinnamon buttercream, homemade caramel between each layer and coating over the cake with those amazing toasty peanut buttery, peanuts *Seasonal: available until 10/30

Pumpkin
A thick, delicious fresh, pumpkin cake with a creamy cinnamon, vanilla buttercream frosting between three layers garnished with candied pecans

Chocolate Salted Caramel
A rich chocolate cake with a fluffy vanilla buttercream with a buttery, homemade salted caramel sauce drizzled on top of the cake

Butterscotch Chip
A butterscotch flavored cake with rich butterscotch chips, a fluffy vanilla buttercream with more butterscotch chips & butterscotch sauce drizzle

Pina Colada
A fresh pineapple cake with chunks of pineapple and a coconut, rum vanilla buttercream with more coconut & cherries on top

Red Velvet
A delicious red velvet cake with a fluffy, cold cream cheese frosting. Perfect with a glass of cold milk!

Lemon Blueberry
A fresh lemon cake with fresh blueberries baked in with a delicious vanilla buttercream and fresh blueberries on top

Millionaires Cake
A thick, chocolate cake with layers of toffee bits, shortbread, a fluffy vanilla buttercream & chocolate ganache and homemade caramel

Caramel Shortbread Latte
A shortbread infused vanilla cake with layers of fresh caramel sauce between each layer. The frosting is made with Baileys Irish Cream and the whole cake is garnished with shortbread cookies

Caramel Gingerbread Crunch
A rich gingerbread cake with a fluffy cinnamon, vanilla frosting with fresh gingerbread cookie bits & a homemade caramel drizzle between each layer & on top of the cake

Reese’s Peanut Butter S’mores Cake
Three layers of a delicious, peanut butter cake, a sweet marshmallow buttercream, chopped Reese’s peanut butter bits & graham crackers between each layer. The whole cake is garnished in toasted mini-mallows and of course whole Reeses’s cups s’mores *Seasonal: available until 10/30

Premium Cake Flavor Pricing
6″ (feeds 5-7) : $55
8″ (feeds 10-15) : $75
10″ (feeds 18-25) : $117
12″ (feeds 25-35) : $154
*Includes delivery within 25 miles of downtown Indianapolis but does not include 9% tax

%d bloggers like this: